Democrats’ reliance on teachers union support and allegiance to underperforming public school systems is a losing political strategy, according to Tommy Schultz, CEO of the conservative advocacy group American Federation for Children (AFC).
“At the end of the day, when you look at the long-term trends here for the teachers unions, they’re in a pickle because more and more folks are listening to the politicians that have a vibrant education agenda,” Schultz told Fox News Digital.
“And they aren’t just saying, ‘We want to block all possible options’ because the unions really don’t have an agenda other than, ‘We want to keep your kids forced to go to the schools that we run and control,'” Schultz added.
“It’s not a winning message at the end of the day.”
Teachers unions consistently oppose many school choice initiatives supported by advocacy organizations like the AFC. They argue that programs such as vouchers and education savings accounts siphon taxpayer funds away from public schools. Union leaders maintain those dollars should instead be directed toward boosting teacher salaries, recruiting staff and upgrading public school buildings.
Democratic candidates in gubernatorial, congressional and state legislative races routinely back education platforms aligned with teachers unions. Financial analyses indicate the nation’s two largest teachers unions — the National Education Association (NEA) and the American Federation of Teachers (AFT) — have spent hundreds of millions of dollars in political activism, lobbying and progressive advocacy over the past decade.
While the NEA and AFT rank among the largest financial contributors to Democratic campaigns, both organizations have occasionally supported select Republican candidates in rural districts who advocated for state aid for underfunded public schools.
Tensions between unions and parents have intensified in recent years, fueled by concerns over learning loss after pandemic-era school closures. In response, Republicans have campaigned heavily on school choice, enacting measures to provide families with state-funded vouchers and education savings accounts to access private or alternative educational settings outside their assigned neighborhood districts.
However, recent Democratic wins in key state races could create headwinds for the school choice movement. In Texas, Democratic Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa has signaled opposition to the state’s school voucher program after defeating Republican Gov. Greg Abbott in the Nov. 3 election.
Hinojosa’s victory raises questions about the future of Abbott’s signature school choice legislation, which established one of the nation’s largest education savings account programs.
“Fundamentally, I think it’s a knee-jerk reaction to the largest funders of the Democratic Party,” Schultz told Fox News Digital. “The teachers unions, they bring in about $3 billion a year for the teachers unions — the two national unions and their affiliates. So, they’re a real big driver of the primary politics and Democratic politics in particular.”
The Texas Education Freedom Accounts (TEFA) program, created by the state legislature with an initial $1 billion allocation, expanded access to private school tuition and other approved education expenses for eligible families. The program allows parents to direct state funds toward alternative education options, raising questions about the potential financial impact on traditional public school districts.
Major urban school districts across the country have faced steep enrollment declines since the COVID-19 pandemic. Some large districts, including Houston Independent School District (HISD), have faced challenges retaining students amid changing enrollment patterns and competition from other education options.
DENVER MOTHER FIGHTS FOR HER DAUGHTER’S EDUCATION AS ADVOCATES MAKE NATIONWIDE SCHOOL CHOICE PUSH
Despite legislative hurdles in some states, Schultz expressed confidence that parental demand for school choice will continue to drive political outcomes.
“What we found over the last chunk of years is that when you actually bring a message of pro-school choice policies and a brighter vision of education — of what could happen to public schools and for families controlling their child’s educational destiny — those candidates win,” Schultz said.
The AFT and Hinojosa did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital’s requests for comment.
The NEA provided Fox News Digital with a statement it released after the Nov. 3 midterm elections.
“Across the nation, most Americans want the same thing — a more affordable future, strong public schools and safer communities. And they’re ready to slam the door on corruption and self-dealing,” National Education Association President Princess Moss said.
“Tonight, voters came together across race, place and gender and sent a clear message and mandate: put working families, students and educators first and deliver for our communities, not billionaires and corporations.”